Dalal Street Blogs provides information for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Please consult a SEBI-registered investment adviser before making any investment decisions.
CAUTION: Dalal Street Blogs publishes market news and educational content only. We do not promote, recommend or endorse any stock, and nothing here is a solicitation to buy or sell securities. Please consult a SEBI-registered adviser before investing.
Technical Analysis

MACD-V Indicator: Volatility-Normalised Momentum You Can Compare Across Stocks

3969
By Dalal Street Blogs EditorialUpdated 9 min read

Put a ₹2,500 stock and a ₹180 stock side by side, pull up the classic MACD on both, and the bigger stock will almost always show the bigger number. That says nothing about which one has stronger momentum. It just tells you one share costs more. The MACD-V indicator fixes this by dividing MACD by volatility, so a reading of 80 on an expensive large-cap means roughly the same thing as 80 on a cheap mid-cap. That one change turns MACD from a chart-by-chart tool into something we can line up across a whole watchlist.

This guide covers where MACD-V came from, the exact formula, the seven momentum zones its creator defined, and a worked example on two hypothetical NSE stocks so you can see the arithmetic for yourself.

In this article
  1. Where the MACD-V indicator came from
  2. The five MACD problems it was designed to solve
  3. How MACD-V is calculated
  4. A worked example on two stocks
  5. The seven momentum zones
  6. Why the boundless scale still matters
  7. Using MACD-V without fooling yourself
  8. MACD-V vs classic MACD at a glance
  9. Where MACD-V fits in your toolkit

Where the MACD-V indicator came from

MACD-V was built by Alex Spiroglou, a technical analyst with the CFTe and DipTA (ATAA) credentials. According to StockCharts’ ChartSchool page on MACD-V, he came up with it in 2015 and published it in 2022 as a research paper. That paper won two prizes: the Founders Award for Advances in Active Investment Management from the National Association of Active Investment Managers (NAAIM), and the Charles H. Dow Award from the CMT Association.

The problem he was attacking is one most of us have run into without naming it. Momentum indicators come in two flavours, and each has a blind spot.

  • Range-bound indicators like RSI and the Stochastic Oscillator live on a fixed 0 to 100 scale. Because the scale is normalised, an RSI of 70 means the same thing on any stock. But in a strong trend these indicators get “pegged” near the top or bottom and stop telling you anything new, and ChartSchool notes they also get skewed by the trend itself.
  • Boundless indicators like MACD and Rate of Change have no ceiling, so they can expand with the market and show how strong a move really is. The catch is that they’re measured in price terms, so you can’t compare them across stocks or even across long stretches of time on the same stock.

MACD-V tries to keep the best part of each: a boundless reading that is also normalised.

The five MACD problems it was designed to solve

ChartSchool lists five limitations of the standard MACD that Spiroglou set out to address:

  1. MACD is not comparable across time.
  2. MACD is not comparable across markets.
  3. MACD has no normalised momentum framework, so there’s no agreed meaning for a reading of, say, 30.
  4. The MACD signal line isn’t accurate.
  5. The MACD signal doesn’t help with timing.

The first two are the ones that bite Indian traders most. Think about a stock that traded at ₹400 five years ago and trades at ₹1,600 now. A MACD value of 10 meant a lot back then and means far less today. Same stock, same indicator, different meaning. Scanning a list of Nifty 50 names for “strongest MACD” runs into the same problem across stocks instead of across years.

How MACD-V is calculated

If you already know the regular MACD, you’re most of the way there. As ChartSchool’s MACD guide explains, the MACD line is the 12-day exponential moving average (EMA) of closing prices minus the 26-day EMA, with a 9-day EMA of that line used as the signal line. MACD-V takes that same gap and divides it by the 26-period Average True Range, then multiplies by 100:

  • MACD-V = [(12-period EMA − 26-period EMA) ÷ ATR(26)] × 100
  • Signal line = 9-period EMA of MACD-V
  • Histogram = MACD-V − signal line

The ATR is the piece doing the heavy lifting. J. Welles Wilder’s Average True Range measures volatility, not direction. Each day’s True Range is the largest of three gaps: today’s high minus today’s low, today’s high minus yesterday’s close, and today’s low minus yesterday’s close (both taken as absolute values). Averaging that over a period gives you the typical daily swing in rupees. We’ve covered ATR in detail in our average true range indicator guide.

One small detail people miss: the usual ATR setting is 14 periods, but MACD-V uses a 26-period ATR, matching the slow EMA. If you build it yourself on a platform that doesn’t offer it ready-made, make sure you change the ATR length, or your readings won’t line up with the zone levels below.

Dividing by ATR answers a simple question: how far apart are the two averages, measured in units of this stock’s own typical daily swing?

That’s the whole idea. Instead of “the 12-day EMA is ₹40 above the 26-day EMA”, MACD-V says “the gap is 0.8 ATRs”, then scales it by 100 to get 80. A rupee gap is meaningless without context. A gap measured in ATRs carries its own context.

A worked example on two stocks

Here are two made-up stocks. The numbers are hypothetical and chosen to keep the arithmetic clean.

Stock A trades near ₹2,500. Its 12-day EMA is ₹2,540, its 26-day EMA is ₹2,500, and its 26-period ATR is ₹50.

  • Classic MACD = 2,540 − 2,500 = 40
  • MACD-V = (40 ÷ 50) × 100 = 80

Stock B trades near ₹180. Its 12-day EMA is ₹182.40, its 26-day EMA is ₹180, and its 26-period ATR is ₹3.20.

  • Classic MACD = 182.40 − 180 = 2.40
  • MACD-V = (2.40 ÷ 3.20) × 100 = 75

Look at the classic MACD and Stock A seems to have more than 16 times the momentum of Stock B (40 against 2.40). That’s pure price-level noise. Once both are expressed in ATR units, they land at 80 and 75, close neighbours. Both trends are pushing about equally hard relative to how much each stock normally moves. If we were scanning a watchlist for the strongest momentum, the classic MACD would have pointed us at the wrong thing.

Now add the signal line. Say Stock A’s MACD-V signal line sits at 70. The histogram is 80 − 70 = 10, positive, so MACD-V is above its signal. With a reading between 50 and 150 and above the signal line, that puts Stock A in the “rallying” zone described next.

The seven momentum zones

This is where MACD-V gets genuinely useful. Because the readings are normalised, Spiroglou could define fixed levels that mean the same thing on any chart. ChartSchool lays out seven momentum stages:

  1. Risk (oversold): MACD-V below −150.
  2. Rebounding: MACD-V between −150 and 50 and above its signal line. The stock is lifting off a low.
  3. Rallying: MACD-V between 50 and 150 and above its signal line. Strong upside momentum.
  4. Risk (overbought): MACD-V above 150 and above its signal line.
  5. Retracing: MACD-V above −50 and below its signal line. The stock is falling back from a high.
  6. Reversing: MACD-V between −50 and −150 and below its signal line. Strong downside momentum.
  7. Ranging: MACD-V stuck between −50 and 50 for more than 20 to 30 bars. A short-term trading range.

A few things stand out. The zones combine two inputs, the level and the position relative to the signal line, so the same reading of 60 can mean “rallying” or “retracing” depending on which side of the signal line it sits. The ±150 lines mark stretched conditions in both directions. And “ranging” is the only zone defined by time, which makes sense: a market that spends weeks hugging zero simply has no momentum worth trading.

Let’s run Stock B through the zones as a hypothetical sequence. Suppose its MACD-V climbs from 75 to 165 over a few weeks while staying above its signal line. It has moved from rallying into the overbought risk zone. That isn’t a sell signal on its own. It’s a flag that the move is now stretched relative to the stock’s own volatility, which is a good moment to tighten a stop rather than add to a position. If MACD-V then rolls over and slips below its signal line while still at, say, 120, the stock has moved into retracing.

Why the boundless scale still matters

Normalising didn’t put a ceiling on MACD-V. ChartSchool makes this point directly: when momentum is very strong, the indicator can keep going and show how big the spike is, because it isn’t capped at 100 or floored at 0 the way RSI is. During a sharp sector rally, RSI on several names might all sit at 80-something and look identical. MACD-V on the same names could read 160, 210 and 250, separating the merely strong from the extreme.

The same idea works on the way down. In a panic sell-off, RSI flattens near the bottom of its range. MACD-V can drop well below −150 and tell you whether this fall is ordinary-bad or unusually violent for that stock.

RSI tells you a stock is overbought. MACD-V tells you how overbought, in the stock’s own units of volatility.

Using MACD-V without fooling yourself

We’d treat MACD-V the way we’d treat any momentum tool: as a filter and a context-setter, not a trigger by itself. A few practical habits help.

Use it to rank, not just to signal. Its biggest edge over classic MACD is comparability. Running a screen of large-caps for MACD-V between 50 and 150 and above signal gives you a short list of names in the rallying stage that you can actually compare with each other.

Respect the ranging zone. When MACD-V hangs between −50 and 50 for weeks, crossovers of the signal line are mostly noise. This is the same chop that ruins plain MACD crossover systems, and our piece on the MACD zero line crossover gets into why whipsaws cluster near zero.

Read the overbought zone as a risk warning. The creator’s own label for readings above 150 is “risk”, not “sell”. Strong stocks can stay stretched for a while. The zone tells you the reward-to-risk on fresh buying has worsened.

Pair it with price structure. MACD-V doesn’t know where support, resistance or a recent breakout level is. Your stop loss and position size still come from the chart and your capital, not from the indicator.

Check your settings. 12, 26 and 9 for the EMAs and signal line, and 26 for the ATR. Change any of them and the ±50 and ±150 levels no longer carry the meaning they were built on.

ChartSchool also mentions that Spiroglou developed a more advanced version that drops the signal line altogether, which makes it quicker to flag momentum changes and to spot highs and lows in the indicator for pattern work. The seven-zone framework above is the version most traders will meet first.

MACD-V vs classic MACD at a glance

FeatureClassic MACDMACD-V
Core calculation12-period EMA minus 26-period EMASame gap divided by 26-period ATR, times 100
UnitsRupees (price units)Multiples of ATR, scaled by 100
Comparable across stocksNoYes
Comparable across yearsNoYes
Fixed overbought/oversold levelsNone+150 and −150
Upper or lower limitNoneNone

Where MACD-V fits in your toolkit

MACD-V is a small change to an old formula, and that’s the point. It keeps MACD’s trend-plus-momentum logic, swaps rupees for ATR units, and in exchange gives us fixed zones that mean the same thing on Reliance-sized names and small caps alike. Use it to rank momentum across a watchlist, to spot when a move is stretched beyond ±150, and to step aside when it’s stuck in the ranging band. For how it sits alongside trend, volume and pattern tools, start with our pillar guide to technical analysis for Indian stocks.

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. The worked examples use hypothetical figures and do not refer to any real stock. Trading in equities and derivatives involves risk of loss; consult a SEBI-registered investment adviser before making investment decisions.

Leave a Reply

Join the conversation

Commenting is open to registered readers. Sign up with just your email — no password needed, and it takes under a minute.

Sign up to comment Log in