The meeting lines candlestick is a two-day pattern built on a coincidence that isn’t really a coincidence. One day the stock moves hard in one direction. The next day it opens well away from that close, runs the other way, and finishes almost exactly where the previous session ended. Two long candles of opposite colour, two closes at the same price. Traders love the drama of it. The test data, as we’ll see, is a lot less dramatic.
In this article
What the meeting lines candlestick looks like
Take the bullish version first. A stock has been falling. Day one is a tall black (down) candle, closing near the lower end of a wide range. Day two opens sharply lower, the kind of gap-down that makes holders reach for the sell button, and then buyers take over. The day ends as a tall white (up) candle, and its close lands right on top of day one’s close. The sellers pushed, the buyers pushed back, and the two lines “meet” at one price.
The bearish version is the mirror image. In an uptrend, a tall white candle is followed by a gap-up open, then selling all day, so the second candle is a tall black one that closes back at the first candle’s close.
Thomas Bulkowski, who tested 103 candlestick patterns across almost 5 million candle lines for his Encyclopedia of Candlestick Charts, keeps the identification rules short. On his bullish meeting lines page:
- Two candle lines.
- The price trend leading into the pattern is downward.
- A tall black candle is followed by a tall white candle.
- The two closes should be near one another.
His bearish meeting lines page flips it: an upward trend, a tall white candle, then a tall black one, with closes “near” each other. He adds, a little drily, “whatever that means”. That throwaway line is the most useful thing on the page, because “near” is exactly where most traders go wrong.
Counterattack lines: the same setup under another name
If you scan for this pattern in software, you may not find “meeting lines” at all. The open-source TA-Lib library, for one, codes it as CDLCOUNTERATTACK. The rule set in that function is the same idea: a long black (or white) first candle, then a long candle of the opposite colour whose close equals the prior close. The function returns +100 when the second candle is white and -100 when it is black.
One thing TA-Lib’s version does not check is the trend before the pattern. Its “must have” list covers only the two candles. So a raw CDLCOUNTERATTACK hit in a sideways market is not a meeting lines pattern in Bulkowski’s sense. You still have to look at what came before.
How “near” the two closes need to be
This is where an exact definition helps. TA-Lib’s default candle settings spell out the two words the pattern depends on:
- Long body: a real body longer than the average real body of the previous 10 candles.
- Equal: a gap of no more than 5% of the average high-low range of the previous 5 candles.
That 5% tolerance is tight. On a stock whose recent candles have averaged an ₹18 range, two closes have to sit within 90 paise of each other to count. A close that misses by ₹2 might look like a match on a zoomed-out chart, but it fails the test. We think that’s a feature, not a bug. The whole message of the pattern is “the move was fully erased”, and a ₹2 miss on an ₹18 range means it wasn’t.
The meeting lines pattern tells you a move was erased. It does not tell you which side wins next, and the numbers say that plainly.
What the test results actually say
Here’s the part that trips up anyone who learnt the pattern from a cheat sheet. Bulkowski’s results for both versions, as published on ThePatternSite:
| Measure | Bullish meeting lines | Bearish meeting lines |
|---|---|---|
| Theoretical behaviour | Bullish reversal | Bearish reversal |
| Tested behaviour | Bullish reversal 56% of the time | Bullish continuation 51% of the time |
| Frequency rank (out of 103) | 72 | 63 |
| Overall performance rank (out of 103) | 18 | 16 |
| Best % meeting price target | 66% (bull market, up breakout) | 60% (bull market, up breakout) |
| Best average move in 10 days | 5.08% (bear market, up breakout) | 7.16% (bear market, up breakout) |
| Best 10-day performance rank | 27 (bull market, up breakout) | 12 (bear market, up breakout) |
Read the second row slowly. The bullish version reverses the downtrend 56% of the time, which Bulkowski himself calls “near random”. The bearish version is worse for anyone shorting on it: it actually acts as a bullish continuation 51% of the time. In plain terms, the pattern doesn’t tell you the breakout direction. A coin toss with extra steps.
So why the respectable overall ranks of 18 and 16? Those ranks reflect what price does after the breakout, not whether you can guess the direction beforehand. Once price breaks out of the bearish pattern, it tends to trend, and the best 10-day average move of 7.16% is above the 6% Bulkowski treats as a good move. The bullish version’s best of 5.08% falls a little short of that bar.
Frequency is the other catch. Ranks of 72 and 63 out of 103 mean you won’t see these often. Strict scans with TA-Lib’s tight “equal” setting will throw up even fewer.
A note on where the numbers come from
The “bull market” and “bear market” labels in Bulkowski’s tables follow his own definition: a bear market is the March 24, 2000 to October 10, 2002 stretch and the October 12, 2007 to March 6, 2009 stretch, and everything outside those is bull market, per his glossary. Those are US market dates. Indian stocks, with their own liquidity, circuit filters and gap behaviour after overnight global cues, may not behave the same way. Treat the stats as a starting bias, not a law.
Trading the pattern: wait for the breakout
Since the pattern can’t call direction, the sensible approach is the one Bulkowski suggests on the bearish page: wait for the breakout, then trade with the trend. His glossary defines a breakout as price moving above the top or below the bottom of the pattern. For a two-candle setup, that means a move past the highest high or the lowest low of the two days.
A few of his tidbits, with the book pages he cites:
- Bullish meeting lines that appear within a third of the yearly low perform best (page 582).
- For the bullish version, reversals happen most often within a third of the yearly high in a bull market (page 585).
- Trade in the direction of the breakout when it agrees with the primary trend (pages 583-584).
- Bearish meeting lines within a third of the yearly low also perform best (page 573).
- A lower close the day after a bearish meeting lines pattern completes suggests a reversal 67% to 70% of the time (page 575).
- Bearish meeting lines in a bear market within a third of the yearly high act as continuations most often (page 576).
“Yearly low” and “yearly high” here mean the thirds of the prior year’s high-low range, counted from the day before the pattern starts. That’s a quick check on any charting platform: take the 52-week high and low, split the gap into three, and see which band the pattern sits in.
The fifth point is the one we’d actually use. With the bearish version, you don’t have to guess on day two. If day three closes lower, the odds tilt toward the reversal. If it doesn’t, stand aside. A day-three check like this is a good habit for other two-candle setups too, including the separating lines pattern.
Worked example: a bullish meeting lines setup, step by step
Let’s run the numbers on an illustrative mid-cap stock. All prices below are hypothetical, chosen to show the arithmetic.
The setup. The stock has been drifting lower for a few weeks. The real bodies of its last 10 candles were ₹9, ₹12, ₹8, ₹14, ₹10, ₹11, ₹13, ₹9, ₹12 and ₹10, an average of ₹10.80. The high-low ranges of the five candles before the pattern were ₹16, ₹19, ₹15, ₹22 and ₹18, an average of ₹18.
Day one. Opens at ₹506, trades up to ₹509, falls to ₹478, closes at ₹481. That’s a black body of ₹25, well above the ₹10.80 average. Long black candle: tick.
Day two. Opens with a gap down at ₹466, dips to ₹461, then rallies to a high of ₹483 and closes at ₹481.40. The body is ₹15.40. Rolling the 10-candle window forward to include day one’s ₹25 body pushes the average up to ₹12.40, and ₹15.40 still clears it. Long white candle: tick.
The “equal” test. The closes are ₹481 and ₹481.40, a gap of 40 paise. The tolerance is 5% of the ₹18 average range, or 90 paise. Forty paise is inside that. Pattern confirmed. Had day two closed at ₹483, the ₹2 gap would have failed it, even though the chart would look much the same.
The breakout levels. The pattern’s high is ₹509 (day one) and its low is ₹461 (day two). So the height is ₹48. An upward breakout is a close above ₹509. A downward breakout is a close below ₹461.
The target. Bulkowski’s candle price target adds the pattern height to the top: ₹509 + ₹48 = ₹557. His glossary also suggests a more modest version, multiplying the height by the percentage of patterns that meet their target. Using the 66% best case for the bullish version: ₹48 × 0.66 = ₹31.68, giving a target of roughly ₹540.68.
The awkward bit. Say you buy on a close of ₹510, just above the breakout. A stop below the pattern low at ₹461 puts ₹49 at risk per share. The modest target is only about ₹30.68 away. That’s a reward-to-risk ratio of about 0.63. Not great.
A wide two-day pattern makes for a wide stop. Do the reward-to-risk sum before the breakout, not after.
This is the practical problem with tall-candle patterns in general. The bigger the two candles, the further away your stop. Traders handle it in different ways: a smaller position so the rupee risk stays fixed, a tighter stop under day two’s close rather than its low (accepting more whipsaws), or simply skipping setups where the numbers don’t work. Our guide to technical analysis for Indian stocks covers position sizing in more detail.
Meeting lines vs lookalike patterns
A few two-candle patterns get confused with this one. Bulkowski points out that the thrusting pattern appears similar. For the bullish version especially, the differences come down to where day two closes:
- Meeting lines: day two closes at (or within a whisker of) day one’s close.
- Thrusting pattern: after a black candle in a downtrend, a white candle opens below the prior low and closes near, but below, the midpoint of the black candle’s body, according to Bulkowski’s thrusting page.
- On-neck pattern: after a tall black candle in a downtrend, the white candle closes at (or nearly at) the prior low, not the prior close. Bulkowski covers it on his on neck page, and we break it down in our on-neck pattern guide.
Mix these up and you’ll be reading the wrong statistics for the setup in front of you.
Mistakes we see with this pattern
Treating it as a reversal signal by default. The textbook name says reversal. The tests say 56% and 51%, which is close to a toss-up. Trade the breakout, not the label.
Being loose about “equal”. Eyeballing a ₹2 or ₹3 gap as a match quietly changes the pattern. If you’re going to rely on someone’s statistics, use a definition close to theirs.
Ignoring the trend before it. TA-Lib’s scan doesn’t check it. Bulkowski’s rules require it. A pair of opposite candles in a flat, choppy range is just noise.
Forgetting the stop distance. As the worked example shows, the reward-to-risk on a straightforward breakout trade can be poor. Check it first.
Assuming US stats carry over unchanged. They’re a reasonable starting point. Keep your own log of how meeting lines behave on the Nifty 500 names you actually trade, and update your view as the sample grows.
Key takeaways
- A meeting lines candlestick is two tall candles of opposite colour whose closes are at, or very near, the same price, following a trend.
- TA-Lib codes the same setup as CDLCOUNTERATTACK and, by default, treats closes as equal when they’re within 5% of the previous five candles’ average range. It doesn’t check the prior trend.
- In Bulkowski’s testing, the bullish version reversed 56% of the time and the bearish version acted as a bullish continuation 51% of the time, so neither reliably predicts direction.
- After the breakout, the moves can be decent: overall performance ranks of 18 and 16 out of 103, with a best 10-day average of 7.16% for the bearish version.
- Wait for a close beyond the pattern’s high or low, size for the wide stop, and use a modest target.
Sources: Thomas Bulkowski, Bullish Meeting Lines and Bearish Meeting Lines (ThePatternSite.com); ThePatternSite glossary; Thrusting and On Neck pattern pages; TA-Lib CDLCOUNTERATTACK source and default candle settings. All example prices are illustrative assumptions.
Disclaimer: This article is for information and education only and is not investment advice. Please do your own research or consult a SEBI-registered investment adviser before making any investment decision.





Leave a Reply
Join the conversation
Commenting is open to registered readers. Sign up with just your email — no password needed, and it takes under a minute.
Sign up to comment Log in