Every few quarters a company announces that it has “redeemed” a batch of preference shares, and most investors scroll right past it. The paperwork behind redeemable preference shares tells you a lot: where the cash came from, whether profits were locked away, and how close the company came to a default. If you read results seriously, this is a corner worth knowing.
Indian company law is blunt about it. Under Section 55 of the Companies Act, 2013, a company limited by shares can’t issue preference shares that are irredeemable at all. Every preference share issued under the Act has to come with an exit date. Below we go through that 20-year ceiling, the two pots of money a company may use to redeem, what happens when it can’t pay, and how the same instrument often turns up as debt in the accounts.
All the legal points come from the Section 55 text and the Share Capital and Debentures Rules reproduced on the same page, plus Section 47 on voting. The rupee figures in the examples are our own, made up to show the mechanics.
In this article
- What Redeemable Preference Shares Actually Promise
- The 20-Year Ceiling, and the Infrastructure Exception
- Only Two Pots of Money Can Fund a Redemption
- Who Pays the Redemption Premium
- Working Through a ₹10 Crore Issue
- When the Company Can’t Pay: The Section 55(3) Route
- Why the Accounts Often Call It Debt
- What to Look For in Quarterly Results
- The Short Version
What Redeemable Preference Shares Actually Promise
A preference share sits between debt and equity. Holders get priority over equity shareholders for dividends and for return of capital, and in exchange they usually give up most voting rights. “Redeemable” simply means the company will buy them back, at par or at a premium, on terms fixed when they were issued.
Rule 9 of the Companies (Share Capital and Debentures) Rules, 2014 spells out what has to be decided upfront. The issue needs a special resolution, and the resolution must set out the dividend priority, whether dividends are cumulative or non-cumulative, any participation in surplus, any conversion into equity, the voting rights, and the redemption terms. The explanatory statement to shareholders has to cover the size of the issue, the price and how it was arrived at, the dividend rate, the redemption tenure and any premium, and the expected dilution if the shares are convertible.
There’s one gate worth remembering. A company can’t issue fresh preference shares while it has a subsisting default, either in redeeming earlier preference shares or in paying dividend due on them. So a company stuck in a default can’t simply roll the problem into a new issue on its own. That route exists, but only through the tribunal, which we come to below.
The 20-Year Ceiling, and the Infrastructure Exception
Section 55(2) allows redeemable preference shares only if the articles of association permit them, and they must be redeemed within 20 years from the date of issue.
Infrastructure companies get more room. Rule 10 lets a company setting up or dealing with infrastructure projects issue preference shares for more than 20 years but not more than 30. The catch: at least 10% of those shares must be redeemed every year from the 21st year onwards, or earlier, on a proportionate basis, at the option of the preference shareholders. What counts as infrastructure is listed in Schedule VI of the Act, and the list is wide: roads, railways, ports, airports, power generation and transmission, telecom networks, water supply, oil and gas pipelines, housing, and more.
Within those limits, Rule 9(6) says redemption can happen on the terms of issue (or as varied with preference shareholders’ approval under Section 48), in one of three ways:
- at a fixed time or on a particular event,
- at any time at the company’s option, or
- at any time at the shareholder’s option.
That third choice matters more than it looks, as the accounting section shows.
Only Two Pots of Money Can Fund a Redemption
Here’s where Section 55 gets strict. The shares can be redeemed only out of:
- profits of the company that would otherwise be available for dividend, or
- the proceeds of a fresh issue of shares made for the purpose of the redemption.
Borrowed money isn’t on the list. Neither is the share capital the preference holders paid in. And only fully paid shares can be redeemed at all.
When profits are used, the Act adds a second step. A sum equal to the nominal value of the shares being redeemed must be moved from those profits into a capital redemption reserve. The reserve is then treated like paid-up share capital for the purposes of capital reduction, so it can’t be quietly paid out later. The one thing the reserve can be used for, under Section 55(4), is paying up unissued shares to be issued to members as fully paid bonus shares.
Redeeming out of profits doesn’t make those profits vanish. It moves an equal amount into a reserve that behaves like share capital, so the creditor cushion stays where it was.
The logic is about creditors. Preference capital is part of the buffer that protects lenders and suppliers. When it is repaid, the law wants that buffer replaced, either with new share capital from a fresh issue or with profits frozen in the reserve.
Who Pays the Redemption Premium
Many issues promise a premium on redemption, say ₹105 back for every ₹100 share. Section 55(2)(d) decides where that premium can come from, and it splits companies in two:
- For the class of companies prescribed for this purpose whose financial statements follow the accounting standards under Section 133, the premium must be provided out of profits before the shares are redeemed. (For preference shares these companies issued on or before the Act came in, the securities premium account is also allowed.)
- For all other companies, the premium can come out of profits or out of the securities premium account.
Either way, the premium has to be provided for before the redemption happens, not patched up afterwards.
Working Through a ₹10 Crore Issue
Let’s take a made-up company, call it Sahyadri Infra-Logistics Ltd, that issued 10 lakh 8% cumulative redeemable preference shares of ₹100 each. That’s ₹10 crore of preference capital, redeemable after five years at a 5% premium.
What has to be paid on the redemption date. The premium is ₹5 per share, so 10 lakh × ₹5 = ₹50 lakh. Total cash out: ₹10 crore of face value plus ₹50 lakh of premium, which is ₹10.5 crore.
Route A: all out of profits. Say the company has enough distributable profit. It pays ₹10.5 crore in cash. It also moves ₹10 crore, the nominal value, from retained earnings to the capital redemption reserve. The ₹50 lakh premium is charged to profits too (or, if the company falls outside the prescribed class, it could use the securities premium account instead). Net worth in total falls only by the cash paid out, but ₹10 crore of what used to be distributable profit is now locked in the reserve.
Route B: a fresh issue. Suppose instead the company raises ₹10 crore through a new equity issue made specifically to redeem the preference shares. Section 55(2)(c) asks for the reserve transfer only where shares are redeemed out of profits, so no capital redemption reserve is created here. The new equity simply replaces the old preference capital. The ₹50 lakh premium still has to be provided for as above.
Route C: a mix. Raise ₹6 crore from a fresh issue and use ₹4 crore of profits. Now the reserve transfer is ₹4 crore, matching only the part funded from profits.
On the results page, Route A shows up as a jump in the capital redemption reserve and a matching drop in retained earnings. Route B shows up as an increase in equity share capital (and possibly securities premium). If you see a redemption with neither, it’s worth opening the notes.
When the Company Can’t Pay: The Section 55(3) Route
Now the uncomfortable case. What if Sahyadri doesn’t have ₹10.5 crore when the redemption date arrives, or hasn’t paid the dividend?
Section 55(3) offers a structured way out, not a free pass. The company may issue further redeemable preference shares equal to the amount due, including dividend, on the unredeemed shares. Two approvals are needed: consent of the holders of three-fourths in value of those preference shares, and approval from the National Company Law Tribunal on a petition filed by the company. Once the new shares are issued, the old ones are treated as redeemed.
On our example, if the amount due were the ₹10.5 crore redemption value plus one year of unpaid dividend at 8% on ₹10 crore (₹80 lakh), the new issue would be for ₹11.3 crore. Measured at the ₹100 issue price, consent from holders of three-fourths in value means holders of at least ₹7.5 crore of the ₹10 crore issue.
What about the holders who say no? The tribunal, while approving, must order that their shares be redeemed immediately. So a dissenting minority gets paid out rather than being forced into the rollover. The Act also clarifies that this exchange is not treated as an increase or reduction of share capital.
A Section 55(3) petition is a company telling the tribunal it can’t meet a promise it made to its preference holders. That’s a credit signal, whatever the press release calls it.
Voting rights shift too. Under Section 47(2), preference holders normally vote only on resolutions that directly affect their rights, on winding up, and on repayment or reduction of equity or preference capital. But if dividend on a class of preference shares hasn’t been paid for two years or more, that class gets the right to vote on every resolution placed before the company. For a promoter, that’s a real cost of letting dividends slide.
Why the Accounts Often Call It Debt
Legally these are shares. In the books of a company following Ind AS, they may well not be. The Ind AS 32 standard on financial instruments says substance beats legal form. Paragraph 18(a) is direct: a preference share that the issuer must redeem for a fixed or determinable amount on a fixed or determinable date, or that the holder can require the issuer to redeem, is a financial liability.
A few details from the standard that matter when you read a balance sheet:
- An issuer’s own option to redeem does not by itself create a liability, because the company has no present obligation to pay. The obligation can arise once it formally notifies holders that it will redeem (AG25).
- A company’s inability to redeem, because of a lack of funds, a statutory restriction or insufficient profits or reserves, does not cancel the obligation (AG25). Section 55’s profits-only rule doesn’t turn the instrument into equity.
- Where shares are wholly a liability, dividends on them are recognised as an expense, the same way as interest on a bond (paragraph 36).
- A non-cumulative share that must be redeemed but pays dividends only at the company’s discretion is a compound instrument: the present value of the redemption amount is the liability, and discretionary dividends are treated as distributions. If unpaid dividends get added to the redemption amount, the whole instrument becomes a liability (AG37).
For our cumulative, mandatorily redeemable Sahyadri issue, that points towards liability treatment, with the 8% dividend, ₹80 lakh a year, flowing through the profit and loss account as an expense rather than appearing as a dividend paid out of profits. Profit before tax looks lower than it would if the same money had been raised as equity, and the debt ratios look higher.
What to Look For in Quarterly Results
When we go through a company’s filings, preference shares are a quick checklist item. Here’s what we look at, in the order it usually helps:
- Where the instrument sits. Is it inside equity or inside financial liabilities? If it’s redeemable at a fixed date or at the holder’s option, liability treatment is what Ind AS 32 points to, and it belongs in your leverage numbers.
- Redemption dates. A large redemption due in the next year is a cash call, just like a maturing loan. Check whether there’s a stated funding plan: profits, or a fresh issue.
- The capital redemption reserve. A rising reserve means redemptions were paid from profits. Compare the movement with the face value redeemed; they should match.
- Dividend arrears. Unpaid cumulative dividends are a warning. Two years of arrears also hands that class of preference holders full voting rights.
- Any Section 55(3) petition. A rollover through the tribunal means the original promise wasn’t met.
This fits into the wider routine of reading a balance sheet and notes, which we cover in our guide on how to analyse the quarterly results of a company.
The Short Version
- Section 55(1) bars companies limited by shares from issuing irredeemable preference shares.
- Redeemable preference shares must be redeemed within 20 years; infrastructure companies can go up to 30 years if at least 10% is redeemed each year from year 21, at the holders’ option.
- Redemption can be funded only from distributable profits or a fresh issue made for that purpose, and only fully paid shares can be redeemed.
- Redeeming from profits requires moving the nominal value to a capital redemption reserve.
- If a company can’t redeem or pay dividend, it can issue new redeemable preference shares with consent of three-fourths in value and NCLT approval; dissenters are paid out immediately.
- Under Ind AS 32, mandatorily redeemable or holder-puttable preference shares are financial liabilities, and their dividends are expensed like interest.
Sources: Companies Act, 2013, Section 55 with Rules 9 and 10 and Schedule VI (ca2013.com); Section 47 (ca2013.com); Ind AS 32, Financial Instruments: Presentation (text). Sahyadri Infra-Logistics Ltd and all example figures are illustrative assumptions.
Disclaimer: This article is for information and education only and is not investment advice. Please do your own research or consult a SEBI-registered investment adviser before making any investment decision.





Leave a Reply
Join the conversation
Commenting is open to registered readers. Sign up with just your email — no password needed, and it takes under a minute.
Sign up to comment Log in