Dalal Street Blogs provides information for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Please consult a SEBI-registered investment adviser before making any investment decisions.
CAUTION: Dalal Street Blogs publishes market news and educational content only. We do not promote, recommend or endorse any stock, and nothing here is a solicitation to buy or sell securities. Please consult a SEBI-registered adviser before investing.
Results

Statement on Impact of Audit Qualifications: Reading the Form That Comes With Annual Results

Statement on impact of audit qualifications: calculator and pen beside a ledger of figures being checked and ticked

Image by 777546 on Pixabay (Pixabay Content License)

By Dalal Street Blogs Editorial10 min read

Most of us skip straight to the profit line when a company posts its annual numbers. Fair enough. But tucked into the same filing, sometimes, is a one- or two-page form called the statement on impact of audit qualifications, and when it shows up, it can matter more than the headline profit. It tells you what the auditor disagreed with, and roughly how different the numbers would look if the company had done things the auditor’s way.

This piece walks through what the statement is, when a listed company has to file it, what each box in the format means, and how to use it. There’s a worked example with made-up figures so you can see the adjustment arithmetic for yourself.

In this article
  1. What the statement on impact of audit qualifications is
  2. Modified opinion, in plain words
  3. What’s inside the format, box by box
  4. Standalone, consolidated, or both?
  5. A worked example with illustrative numbers
  6. How to actually use the statement
  7. Who keeps an eye on these filings
  8. A few common misreadings
  9. The short version

What the statement on impact of audit qualifications is

Under Regulation 33(3)(d) of the SEBI Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements (LODR) Regulations, a listed entity has to submit its audited standalone results for the financial year within sixty days of the year ending. Along with them go the audit report and one of two things. If the audit opinion is unmodified (a “clean” report), the company files a declaration saying so. If the opinion is modified, it files the statement on impact of audit qualifications. SEBI’s own FAQs on the LODR Regulations spell out this either-or structure.

The format itself comes from SEBI circular CIR/CFD/CMD/56/2016 dated May 27, 2016. Before that, companies filed a “Form A” for a clean report and a “Form B” for a modified one. The 2016 circular scrapped Form A and Form B, and it also dropped the older requirement that companies adjust their books in the following year for the qualifications. In their place came a single format that shows the cumulative impact of all the qualifications, filed at the same time as the annual results. The circular applied to annual audited results for periods ending on or after March 31, 2016.

The circular says why: so the information reaches investors without delay and they can make informed decisions. That’s the whole point. The company can’t bury the disagreement in a note on page 180 of the annual report months later. It has to sit next to the results on the day they go to the exchange.

Modified opinion, in plain words

An auditor’s opinion is “modified” when it isn’t a clean sign-off. The SEBI format names three types, and the company has to tick which one applies:

  • Qualified opinion. The auditor says the accounts are fine “except for” one or more specific matters. It’s the mildest of the three.
  • Adverse opinion. The auditor says the accounts, taken as a whole, don’t give a true and fair view. That’s a serious finding.
  • Disclaimer of opinion. The auditor says it couldn’t get enough evidence to form an opinion at all.

An “emphasis of matter” paragraph, where the auditor simply draws attention to something already disclosed, isn’t one of the three types the format lists. So don’t panic every time you see the auditor flag something. Check which box is ticked.

A qualification is the auditor saying “these numbers are right, except for this bit.” The statement is where the company has to put a rupee figure on “this bit.”

What’s inside the format, box by box

The format in Annexure I of the 2016 circular has three parts. Here’s what each one asks for and what to look for.

Part I: the before-and-after table

This is the bit most investors should read first. It has two columns: audited figures as reported (before adjusting for qualifications) and adjusted figures (after adjusting for qualifications). The rows are fixed:

  1. Turnover / Total income
  2. Total expenditure
  3. Net profit / (loss)
  4. Earnings per share
  5. Total assets
  6. Total liabilities
  7. Net worth
  8. Any other financial item the management thinks appropriate

If the two columns are identical, that usually means the impact wasn’t quantified, not that there’s no impact. Read Part II before you relax.

Part II: each qualification separately

For every qualification, the company has to give:

  • Details of the qualification.
  • Type: qualified, adverse or disclaimer.
  • Frequency: whether it’s appearing for the first time, is repetitive, and since how long it has continued.
  • Management’s views, where the auditor has quantified the impact.
  • Where the auditor hasn’t quantified it: management’s own estimate of the impact, or, if it can’t estimate, the reasons why, plus the auditor’s comments on either.

That last point comes straight from the circular. Where the auditor doesn’t quantify the impact, management has to make an estimate, and if it can’t, it has to say why. In both cases, the auditor reviews and comments. So a company can’t just write “not quantifiable” and move on without the auditor weighing in.

The frequency line is underrated. A first-time qualification on a one-off issue is one thing. The same qualification showing up for the fourth year running tells you the issue isn’t being fixed, and that the board is comfortable living with it.

Part III: who signs it

The format lists four signatories: the CEO or Managing Director, the CFO, the Audit Committee Chairman and the Statutory Auditor. That’s a fair bit of accountability on one page. If the auditor’s comments and management’s views read like they’re describing two different companies, that tells you something about the relationship.

Standalone, consolidated, or both?

Many listed companies have subsidiaries and publish two sets of results. SEBI’s FAQ handles this directly. If both the standalone and consolidated audit reports carry a modified opinion, the company files a separate statement for each. If only one of them is modified, it files the statement only for that one. And if both are clean, it can file one common declaration of unmodified opinion covering both.

In practice, this means you should check which set of numbers the statement relates to. A qualification only on the consolidated accounts often points to a subsidiary, a joint venture or an overseas unit where the group auditor couldn’t get enough comfort.

A worked example with illustrative numbers

Let’s make this concrete. The company and figures below are invented for teaching purposes only.

Say a hypothetical company, call it ABC Industries, reports these annual standalone numbers (₹ crore):

ItemAs reported
Total income1,200
Total expenditure1,050
Tax38
Net profit112
Shares outstanding (crore)20
EPS (₹)5.60
Total assets2,000
Total liabilities1,100
Net worth900

The auditor qualifies the opinion. A customer owing ₹40 crore has gone into insolvency proceedings, and the company hasn’t made any provision against that receivable. The auditor quantifies the impact at ₹40 crore. To keep the arithmetic simple, assume there’s no tax effect on the provision.

Here’s how Part I of the statement would look:

ItemAudited (before adjustment)Adjusted (after qualification)
Total income1,2001,200
Total expenditure1,0501,090
Net profit11272
EPS (₹)5.603.60
Total assets2,0001,960
Total liabilities1,1001,100
Net worth900860

Walk through it. The provision adds ₹40 crore to expenses, so expenditure goes from 1,050 to 1,090. Income doesn’t change. Net profit drops from 112 to 72 (1,200 minus 1,090 minus 38 in tax). EPS is 72 divided by 20 crore shares, which is ₹3.60. On the balance sheet, the receivable shrinks by ₹40 crore, so total assets fall to 1,960. Liabilities stay at 1,100. Net worth falls to 860, and the sum still checks out: 1,100 plus 860 is 1,960.

Now the part that matters for valuation. The ₹40 crore is a 35.7% cut to net profit (40 divided by 112), but only a 4.4% cut to net worth (40 divided by 900). So if you value ABC on earnings, this qualification is huge. If you value it on book, it’s modest. The same qualification can look very different depending on which lens you use, and the table gives you both numbers without making you dig.

One qualification wiped out over a third of ABC’s profit but less than a twentieth of its net worth. The lens you value a stock with decides how much a qualification should worry you.

A second case: the impact isn’t quantified

Change the story. This time the auditor says it couldn’t verify inventory at a plant because it wasn’t able to attend the stock count, and it can’t say what the impact is. Now the adjusted column might look identical to the reported one.

Here, Part II has to carry the weight. Management must either give its own estimate or explain why it can’t, and the auditor has to comment on that. Read those two paragraphs side by side. If management says the inventory is fine and the auditor says it has no basis to agree, you’re effectively looking at profits you can’t rely on for that plant. If you want to see how inventory problems flow through results in general, our piece on inventory write-downs covers the mechanics.

How to actually use the statement

We’d suggest a simple routine when you see one:

  1. Find it. It’s filed with the annual results on the exchange. If the company has a clean opinion, you’ll see the declaration instead.
  2. Check the type. Qualified is a caution flag. Adverse or disclaimer is a much bigger one.
  3. Compare the two columns. Work out the percentage hit to net profit and to net worth yourself, like we did above. Which one matters depends on how you value the business.
  4. Read the frequency line. A repeat qualification is a governance signal, not just an accounting one.
  5. Read management’s view and the auditor’s comment together. Agreement is reassuring. Two parties talking past each other isn’t.
  6. Use the adjusted numbers in your ratios. If you calculate P/E or return on equity, run it on the adjusted figures as well as the reported ones.

It also helps to know the other audit-related documents. Quarterly numbers usually come with a limited review rather than a full audit; our explainer on the limited review report covers how that differs. And the CARO report annexed to the audit report often hints at the same problems a qualification later spells out. For the wider picture of reading results, start with our guide on how to analyse quarterly results of a company.

Who keeps an eye on these filings

The 2016 circular makes these statements part of the stock exchanges’ regular monitoring under Regulation 97 of the Listing Regulations. If a company doesn’t comply, the exchanges can take action as they see fit and report to SEBI on a regular basis. Where a stock is listed on more than one exchange, the exchanges are expected to coordinate.

That’s oversight of the filing, though, not a judgement on the stock. The exchange checking that a company filed the statement properly doesn’t tell you whether the qualification is a minor timing dispute or a sign of something worse. That call is still ours to make.

A few common misreadings

“Identical columns mean no problem.” Not necessarily. It may just mean the impact wasn’t quantified. Go to Part II.

“Management disagrees, so the auditor must be overcautious.” The format gives management an option to explain its views. That’s a right of reply, not a verdict. Weigh both.

“It’s only on consolidated, so the parent is fine.” Maybe. But if the subsidiary is a big chunk of group revenue or carries group debt, a consolidated qualification can matter as much as a standalone one.

“It’s an old qualification, the market already knows.” Perhaps. Still, a qualification that keeps repeating tells you the issue isn’t being resolved, and that’s worth factoring into how much you trust the rest of the accounts.

The short version

The statement on impact of audit qualifications is the one place where a listed company has to show, in a fixed table, what its annual numbers would look like if the auditor’s objections were accepted. It’s filed with the results, signed by the CEO, CFO, audit committee chair and the statutory auditor, and it has to explain any impact that isn’t quantified. Five minutes with it, comparing the two columns and reading the frequency line, can save you from valuing a company on profits its own auditor wouldn’t sign off on.

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. The company and figures in the worked example are hypothetical. Please do your own research or consult a SEBI-registered adviser before making investment decisions.

Leave a Reply

Join the conversation

Commenting is open to registered readers. Sign up with just your email — no password needed, and it takes under a minute.

Sign up to comment Log in