Dalal Street Blogs provides information for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Please consult a SEBI-registered investment adviser before making any investment decisions.
CAUTION: Dalal Street Blogs publishes market news and educational content only. We do not promote, recommend or endorse any stock, and nothing here is a solicitation to buy or sell securities. Please consult a SEBI-registered adviser before investing.
Technical Analysis

Deliberation Candlestick Pattern: When Three White Candles Start to Hesitate

3979
By Dalal Street Blogs EditorialUpdated 10 min read

Three green candles in a row look like good news. Buyers showed up on day one, came back on day two, and were still around on day three. But look closely at that third candle. If its body has shrunk to a sliver while the first two were tall and confident, you are probably looking at the deliberation candlestick pattern, and it tells a slightly more complicated story than “the bulls are winning”.

We like this pattern as a teaching tool because it forces a trader to read candle size, not just candle colour. It also comes with an inconvenient twist that most textbook descriptions skip: when Thomas Bulkowski tested it on historical data, the pattern did not behave the way the theory says it should. More on that below, because it changes how you should trade it.

In this article
  1. What the deliberation candlestick pattern looks like
  2. Deliberation vs three white soldiers vs advance block
  3. The theory says reversal. The testing says otherwise.
  4. Where it forms matters more than how it looks
  5. A worked example (hypothetical numbers)
  6. Spotting it on Indian charts
  7. Mistakes we see traders make with this pattern
  8. A short checklist before you act

What the deliberation candlestick pattern looks like

According to Bulkowski’s identification guidelines on ThePatternSite, the deliberation has three parts, and all three matter:

  • The trend before it is up. This is a pattern that shows up after prices have already been rising. Three white candles after a fall are a different animal.
  • Three white (bullish) candles. Each candle opens and closes higher than the one before it.
  • Two tall bodies, then a small one. The first two candles have tall bodies. The third has a small body and opens near the second day’s close.

That last point is the whole idea. Day three opens roughly where day two ended, so there is no gap-up excitement, and then it barely moves from its open to its close. The buyers are still technically in charge, since the candle closes higher, but they are hesitating. That hesitation is the “deliberation” in the name: the market seems to be thinking about whether the move has gone far enough.

The colour of the third candle says the bulls won the day. Its size says they barely bothered to show up.

Deliberation vs three white soldiers vs advance block

Three patterns use three rising white candles, and they get mixed up all the time. Here is how we separate them.

Three white soldiers come after a downward price trend, which is why they are read as a bullish reversal. Bulkowski’s page notes this directly when he points readers to the soldiers as the related pattern for advancing candles after a decline. We covered that setup in detail in our post on the three white soldiers pattern.

The advance block appears in an uptrend, like the deliberation. Bulkowski’s advance block page describes it as three white candles where each one opens within the body of the previous candle, and where the shadows get taller on the last two candles. So the warning sign there is in the upper wicks: price keeps getting pushed up intraday and then sold back.

The deliberation also appears in an uptrend, but the test is the body height. Bulkowski points out that the deliberation has requirements on body height and none on the upper shadow, which is exactly the opposite emphasis from the advance block. In plain terms: the advance block warns you through the wicks, the deliberation warns you through the shrinking third body.

If you are still getting comfortable with bodies, shadows and what each part of a candle means, our candlestick patterns for beginners guide is a better starting point than this one.

The theory says reversal. The testing says otherwise.

Classic candlestick literature treats the deliberation as a bearish reversal: the uptrend is tiring, so expect a turn lower. Bulkowski’s tested numbers, published on the same Deliberation page, paint a different picture. Here is what he reports, with each figure explained, because the context of each number matters:

  • Tested behaviour: a bullish continuation 77% of the time. In other words, in his test, price more often broke out above the top of the pattern than below the bottom of it.
  • Overall performance rank: 93 out of 103 candlestick patterns, where 1 is the best. That is near the bottom of the list.
  • Frequency rank: 48 out of 103, so it is fairly common and you will find plenty of examples.
  • Best percentage meeting the price target: 36%, in a bull market with an upward breakout.
  • Best average move 10 days after the breakout: a drop of 6.72%, in a bear market with a downward breakout.
  • Best 10-day performance rank: 6 out of 103, for a downward breakout in a bull market.

Bulkowski himself is candid about the 77% figure. He says the way he measured it is probably to blame: since the third candle leaves price near the top of the pattern, it is far more likely that price closes above the top first than that it falls all the way through the bottom. So the “continuation” result partly reflects geometry, not some hidden bullish power.

For comparison, his advance block page reports a bullish continuation rate of 64%, an overall performance rank of 54 and a frequency rank of 65, all out of the same 103 patterns. He also writes that the deliberation works better than the advance block as a bullish continuation pattern, ranking second there, even though its overall performance is near the end of the pack.

What do we take from this? Two things. First, do not short a stock just because a deliberation formed. The odds in the test favoured an upside break. Second, when the pattern does break down, the moves can be meaningful, which is why the downside numbers rank well. The pattern is less a signal and more a prompt to tighten up.

Treat the deliberation as a reason to manage a trade more carefully, not as a reason to flip your view on the stock.

Where it forms matters more than how it looks

Bulkowski lists three trading tidbits from his Encyclopedia of Candlestick Charts for this pattern, and they are worth reading slowly:

  1. Deliberation candles that appear within a third of the yearly low perform best.
  2. Selecting tall candles gives better performance.
  3. Deliberations within a third of the yearly high act as continuations most often.

Put the first and third points together and you get a practical filter. A deliberation forming near a stock’s 52-week high is, on his data, more likely to resolve upward than downward. A deliberation forming in the lower third of the yearly range is where the pattern’s performance is strongest. So before you react to the candles, check where the stock sits in its 12-month range. That one step does more work than staring at the bodies.

A worked example (hypothetical numbers)

The prices below are made up purely to show the mechanics. They do not describe any real stock.

Say a mid-cap stock has been climbing for three weeks. Then we get these three daily candles:

  • Day 1: opens at Rs 500, closes at Rs 524. Body of Rs 24.
  • Day 2: opens at Rs 522, closes at Rs 547. Body of Rs 25.
  • Day 3: opens at Rs 547, closes at Rs 551. Body of Rs 4.

Check it against the rules. The trend before it is up. All three candles are white. Each opens and closes higher than the previous one (500, 522, 547 for the opens; 524, 547, 551 for the closes). The first two bodies are tall, and the third body is tiny at Rs 4, opening right at the previous close. That fits the deliberation.

Now the levels. The top of the pattern is Day 3’s high; suppose that high is Rs 556. The bottom of the pattern is Day 1’s low; suppose that low is Rs 497. A close above Rs 556 would be the upward breakout. A close below Rs 497 would be the downward breakout. Notice how much further price has to travel to break down (about 54 rupees from the Rs 551 close) than to break up (about 5 rupees). That is the geometry Bulkowski is talking about.

How might a swing trader already long from Rs 480 handle this?

  • Do not panic-sell. The pattern alone is not a sell signal.
  • Raise the stop. A stop just below Day 2’s open at Rs 522 locks in part of the move without waiting for the full pattern low at Rs 497.
  • Watch the next close. A strong close above Rs 556 on rising volume says the pause was just a breather. A weak close that slips back into Day 2’s body says the hesitation is spreading.
  • Check the yearly range. If Rs 551 is close to the stock’s 52-week high, the testing suggests continuation is the more common outcome. If the whole run started from near the yearly low, stay alert for the downside version.

A trader looking for a fresh long entry would do the reverse: wait for the close above the pattern high rather than buying the small third candle, since buying into hesitation is exactly what the pattern warns against.

Spotting it on Indian charts

A few practical notes for the NSE and BSE screens most of us use.

Use daily candles. On five-minute charts, three rising candles with a small third body happen constantly and mean very little. Bulkowski’s statistics are for daily price data, so stick to that timeframe if you want the numbers to apply even loosely.

Define “tall” and “small” for yourself. There is no fixed rupee size. Compare the bodies with the stock’s recent candles. A Rs 25 body is huge on a Rs 200 stock and ordinary on a Rs 5,000 stock. A simple rule is to call a body tall if it is clearly larger than most of the last ten or so bodies, and small if it is a fraction of the two before it.

Mind results days and news gaps. If the third candle is small because the stock is waiting for quarterly numbers or a board meeting the next morning, the hesitation has an obvious cause. The pattern is not telling you much beyond “traders are waiting”.

Look at volume. A small third body on falling volume reads as quiet consolidation. A small body on a big volume spike is more interesting, because a lot of shares changed hands and price still went nowhere. Our guide on volume confirmation in trading covers how to read that.

Mistakes we see traders make with this pattern

Calling every small third candle a deliberation. If the first two candles are not tall, there is no contrast and no pattern. The shrinkage is the signal.

Ignoring the opening condition. The third candle should open near the second day’s close. A big gap-up followed by a small body is a different setup, and some traders would read it closer to a star.

Confusing it with the advance block. If the warning is in long upper shadows and each candle opens inside the prior body, check the advance block rules instead.

Shorting on sight. We keep coming back to this because it is the costly one. Bulkowski’s own test found upward breakouts far more common. A short trade needs the downward breakout to actually happen first.

Forgetting the bigger picture. A single candle pattern sits inside support, resistance, trend and market mood. In his chart example, Bulkowski notes the trend stopped when it hit overhead resistance near the top of the pattern. The resistance did the heavy lifting, and the candles simply showed it.

A short checklist before you act

  1. Is the prior trend clearly up on the daily chart?
  2. Are all three candles white, each opening and closing higher?
  3. Are the first two bodies tall and the third small, opening near the second close?
  4. Where is the stock in its 52-week range: upper third, lower third, or the middle?
  5. Where are the pattern high and pattern low, and which one breaks first?
  6. Is there an event (results, board meeting, index rebalance) explaining the pause?
  7. What does volume say on the small third candle?

Candle patterns work best as one input among several. For the wider toolkit, including trend, indicators and support and resistance, see our pillar guide to technical analysis for Indian stocks.

Disclaimer: This article is for education only and is not investment advice. The worked example uses hypothetical prices. Pattern statistics come from a third-party historical study and do not guarantee future results. Please consult a SEBI-registered investment adviser before making investment decisions.

Leave a Reply

Join the conversation

Commenting is open to registered readers. Sign up with just your email — no password needed, and it takes under a minute.

Sign up to comment Log in