Most people who open a red herring prospectus jump to two places: the price band and the objects of the issue. Fair enough. But the section that tells you how the business actually behaved over the last three years sits further down, and it’s written by the company itself. The management discussion and analysis in RHP documents, usually shortened to MD&A, is where the promoters and the finance team explain why revenue rose, why margins moved and what they think could go wrong. It’s their story about their numbers. Our job as readers is to check whether the story and the numbers agree.
This piece walks through what SEBI requires the section to contain, what each requirement is really trying to flush out, and how to test an MD&A with a simple worked example.
In this article
Where management discussion and analysis in RHP sits, and why it exists
The disclosure list for an offer document is in Schedule VI, Part A of SEBI’s Issue of Capital and Disclosure Requirements (ICDR) Regulations, 2018, in the version amended up to March 21, 2026. Under the financial statements item, the regulation asks for a “Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Position and Results of Operations” as part of the other financial information.
Two details in that wording matter. First, the discussion has to be based on the restated financial information for the last three years and the stub period, if there is one. So the MD&A talks about the same numbers you see in the restated financial statements, not some separate management cut. Second, the regulation spells out the same MD&A list whether the restated accounts are under Ind AS or the older Indian GAAP. The format of the accounts changes; the questions the company must answer don’t.
Why have it at all? Because a profit and loss statement tells you what happened and almost nothing about why. Revenue up 24% could mean the company sold a lot more, or sold the same amount at higher prices, or booked one large order that won’t repeat. The MD&A is supposed to separate those.
The checklist SEBI gives the company
The ICDR list is long, but it falls into four buckets. Here’s each one in plain language.
1. Anything big since the last balance sheet
The directors have to state whether, in their opinion, any circumstances have arisen since the date of the last financial statements in the offer document that materially and adversely affect, or are likely to affect within the next twelve months, three things: the trading or profitability of the company, the value of its assets, or its ability to pay its liabilities.
This is usually a short paragraph, and most of the time it says nothing material has happened. Read it anyway. The gap between the last audited period and the IPO date can run several months, and a lost contract or a plant shutdown in that window would have to show up here.
2. Factors that may affect results
The regulation simply asks for “factors that may affect the results of operations”. In practice this becomes a list of the company’s key business drivers: raw material prices, capacity utilisation, customer contracts, exchange rates, regulation. It’s a useful map of what the company itself thinks moves its earnings. Compare it with the risk factors section. If something shows up as a major driver here but is barely mentioned in the risks, ask why.
3. Discussion of the results
This is the meat. SEBI wants, among other things:
- A summary of past results from the restated financials for three full years and the stub period, with significant items of income and expenditure.
- Income and sales broken down by major product or main activity.
- If other income is more than 10% of total income, a break-up of it, stating whether each part is recurring or non-recurring.
- If a material part of income depends on a single customer or supplier, or a few of them, that fact along with relevant data. If a foreign customer or supplier is significant, the company also has to discuss the exchange-rate impact.
- Any deviation from accounting standards in recording sales and revenue, with its impact.
- The nature of miscellaneous income and expenditure.
4. Year-on-year comparison with reasons
The company has to compare the last three years and the stub period on the major profit and loss heads and explain the reasons for changes. The regulation lists what this should cover, including:
- Unusual or infrequent events, including changes in accounting policy and discretionary cuts in expenses.
- Significant economic changes that affected, or are likely to affect, income from continuing operations.
- Known trends or uncertainties expected to have a material adverse impact on sales or income.
- Expected changes in the relationship between costs and revenue, such as known increases in labour or material costs.
- The extent to which revenue growth came from higher volumes, new products or higher prices.
- Turnover of each major industry segment, the status of any announced new products or segments, seasonality, dependence on a few suppliers or customers, and competitive conditions.
The MD&A is the one section where the company has to explain the why behind its revenue. If the why is missing, the omission is itself a finding.
Read that list once more and you’ll notice what SEBI is fishing for. Every item is a way a reported number could flatter the business: a one-off, a temporary price spike, a single big customer, interest income dressing up a thin operating profit. The MD&A is where the company is forced to say so in words.
A worked example: is the growth volume, price or something else?
Let’s take a made-up company. These numbers are hypothetical and only meant to show the method.
Say its restated accounts show revenue from operations of ₹800 crore in year one and ₹990 crore in year two. That’s growth of ₹190 crore, or 23.75%. The MD&A says it sold 40 lakh units in year one and 44 lakh in year two, and the average realisation per unit went from ₹2,000 to ₹2,250.
First, check that the story adds up. 40 lakh units at ₹2,000 is ₹800 crore. 44 lakh units at ₹2,250 is ₹990 crore. Good, the units and prices reconcile with the revenue line.
Now split the ₹190 crore of growth:
- Volume effect: the extra 4 lakh units at the old price of ₹2,000 adds ₹80 crore.
- Price effect: the ₹250 rise in price across all 44 lakh units adds ₹110 crore.
₹80 crore plus ₹110 crore is ₹190 crore. So roughly 42% of the growth came from selling more and about 58% from charging more. That changes how we’d read the business. Volume growth of 10% is decent, but most of the jump came from price. The next question is obvious: why could it raise prices by 12.5%? If the MD&A says it passed on a raw material spike, that price gain may reverse when input costs fall. If it says a new premium product changed the mix, that’s more durable. This is exactly the “volume, new products or prices” disclosure SEBI asks for, and it’s worth more than any adjective in the business overview.
The other income test
Same hypothetical company. Suppose total income in year two is ₹1,140 crore: ₹990 crore of operations plus ₹150 crore of other income. Other income is then about 13.2% of total income, above the 10% line in the regulation, so the company has to break it up and label each part recurring or non-recurring.
Now suppose profit before tax is ₹200 crore. Other income of ₹150 crore is 75% of that pre-tax profit. If the break-up shows ₹120 crore was a one-time gain on selling land, the operating business is earning far less than the headline profit suggests. A price-to-earnings multiple built on ₹200 crore of pre-tax profit would be built on sand.
We see this pattern more often than you’d think in issuers that recently sold a division or hold large treasury investments. The ICDR threshold is there precisely so this doesn’t stay buried in a note.
Customer concentration
One more check. If the MD&A says the top customer contributes 35% of revenue in our example, ask what the contract looks like. Is it a multi-year supply agreement or purchase orders renewed every quarter? Does the company sell to that customer in dollars? The regulation requires a foreign customer or supplier that’s a significant part of the business to come with a discussion of exchange-rate impact, so look for it. Concentration also tends to show up in related party transactions in the RHP when the big customer is a group company, so read those two sections together.
How to read an MD&A without getting lost
An MD&A in a large IPO can run to dozens of pages. Here’s a routine that keeps it manageable.
- Read the three-year table first. Before any explanation, note the direction of revenue, EBITDA margin and profit after tax. Write down your own question for each big move.
- Find the answers in the comparison section. The year-on-year discussion is required to give reasons. See if it actually answers your questions or just restates the numbers with words like “primarily due to an increase in business”.
- Look for volume and price. If the company sells physical goods and the MD&A doesn’t split growth between volume and realisation, that’s a gap worth noting.
- Check other income. Compute it as a share of total income and of profit before tax yourself.
- Read the “significant developments” paragraph. It’s short, and it’s the most recent information in the document.
- Cross-check debt. Rising finance costs in the MD&A should match what you see in the financial indebtedness section of the RHP.
Write your own questions from the numbers before you read management’s explanation. Otherwise their framing becomes your framing.
Red flags that show up in this section
None of these alone is a reason to skip an issue. Together, they should make you slow down.
- Explanations that only restate the number. “Revenue increased by ₹190 crore due to higher sales” tells you nothing.
- A stub period that looks very different from the full years. Seasonality is a legitimate reason, and SEBI asks the company to state the extent to which the business is seasonal. If it doesn’t, you can’t compare a six-month stub with a full year.
- Accounting policy changes near the IPO. The comparison section has to flag changes in accounting policy. A change that boosts revenue recognition in the year before listing deserves attention.
- Discretionary cost cuts. SEBI specifically mentions discretionary reductions in expenses as an unusual item. Slashing marketing or maintenance spend can lift margins for a year or two before an IPO.
- Known cost increases mentioned only briefly. If the company says it expects labour or material costs to rise, think through what that does to the margin you’re paying for.
Where to find it
Draft and final offer documents are on SEBI’s public issues filings page. In most documents the MD&A follows the restated financial information, often under a heading close to SEBI’s own wording. Use the table of contents; offer documents are long, and the page numbers save time. For the bigger picture of how an issue works, our guide to IPO investing in India covers the full process.
The takeaway
The management discussion and analysis in an RHP is the company’s explanation of its own restated numbers, and SEBI’s ICDR rules tell it what that explanation must cover: recent adverse developments, the drivers of results, product-wise income, other income above 10% of total income, customer and supplier dependence, and a reasoned three-year comparison including volume versus price. Use it as a test, not a narrative. Reconcile the units and prices with revenue, work out how much profit comes from other income, and check whether the reasons given are real reasons. When the story and the numbers line up, you’ve learned something about the business. When they don’t, you’ve learned something more useful.
Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. The worked examples use hypothetical numbers. Investing in equities and IPOs involves risk of loss. Please consult a SEBI-registered investment adviser before making investment decisions.





Leave a Reply
Join the conversation
Commenting is open to registered readers. Sign up with just your email — no password needed, and it takes under a minute.
Sign up to comment Log in