Every fund house has a green-looking factsheet these days. A leaf in the logo, a wind turbine on the cover, the word “sustainable” somewhere near the top. None of that tells you what the fund actually owns. An ESG fund in India is supposed to be different from a marketing label, because SEBI has written down what it must invest in, what it must call itself and what it must disclose every month and every year. The catch is that most investors never read those rules, so they can’t tell a fund that is doing the work from one that is just using the vocabulary.
This guide walks through the rulebook as it stands in SEBI’s Master Circular for Mutual Funds dated March 20, 2026, explains where BRSR Core fits in, and then shows, with a couple of made-up portfolios, how we’d check whether an ESG scheme is living up to its name.
In this article
Where an ESG fund sits in SEBI’s scheme categories
SEBI treats ESG as a separate sub-category inside the thematic category of equity schemes. So an ESG fund is, first of all, an equity fund. It carries equity risk, it can fall as hard as the market, and it has nothing to do with debt or “safe” investing. If you’ve read our explainer on the sectoral and thematic fund category, the same logic applies: the theme narrows what the manager can buy, which can mean more concentration than a diversified flexi-cap fund.
Each ESG scheme has to be launched with one of six strategies, defined in Annexure 3 of the master circular:
- Exclusion keeps out securities based on certain ESG-related activities, business practices or segments. The fund has to spell out the type of exclusion (adverse impact, controversy or faith), the threshold for exclusion and any law or third-party standard it relies on.
- Integration means ESG factors that are material to risk and return are considered explicitly, alongside the usual financial analysis.
- Best-in-class and positive screening aims to own companies that do better than their peers on one or more ESG metrics, and the fund must disclose which metrics.
- Impact investing seeks a positive, measurable social or environmental impact alongside a financial return, and has to explain the methodology used to assess that impact.
- Sustainable objectives targets sectors, industries or companies expected to benefit from long-term ESG-related trends, with the rationale for that focus.
- Transition or transition-related investments targets companies that support environmental transition and just transition.
These aren’t small differences. An exclusion fund might still hold a large power utility if that utility clears its screens; a best-in-class fund might hold it only if it scores better than other utilities. Same word “ESG” on the label, quite different portfolios underneath.
The two numbers that matter: 80% and 65%
SEBI sets the asset allocation in two layers, and it’s worth separating them clearly.
The 80% rule. At least 80% of the scheme’s total assets under management (AUM) must be in equity and equity-related instruments aligned with the scheme’s chosen ESG strategy. The remaining portion, up to 20%, can’t be invested in anything that contradicts that strategy. The circular also says funds should try to put a higher share than the minimum into the selected strategy and disclose it.
The 65% rule. At least 65% of AUM must be in companies that report a comprehensive Business Responsibility and Sustainability Report (BRSR) and also provide assurance on their BRSR Core disclosures. The rest of the AUM can be in companies that have BRSR disclosures.
Notice what the 65% test checks. It doesn’t ask whether a company is “green”. It asks whether the company’s sustainability data has been reported in the full format and checked by someone independent. That’s a data-quality filter, not a virtue filter, and frankly it’s the more useful of the two for an investor.
The 65% rule doesn’t ask whether a company is green. It asks whether its sustainability numbers have been checked by someone independent, and that is the more useful question.
Worked example: testing a portfolio against both rules
Take a hypothetical ESG fund with AUM of ₹1,000 crore. These figures are illustrative only and don’t describe any real scheme.
- Equity aligned with its stated best-in-class strategy: ₹860 crore
- Equity in companies the fund owns for liquidity but which don’t score as best-in-class: ₹90 crore
- Cash and money market: ₹50 crore
The 80% test needs at least ₹800 crore (80% of ₹1,000 crore) aligned with the strategy. ₹860 crore clears it, at 86%. The other ₹140 crore sits in the residual bucket, and the question there is only whether any of it runs against the strategy. Cash doesn’t; a stock that the fund’s own screen would rank at the bottom of its sector arguably could, and that’s the kind of holding we’d look at closely.
Now the 65% test. Suppose, within the equity book, ₹700 crore is in companies filing comprehensive BRSR with BRSR Core assurance, and ₹250 crore is in companies with BRSR disclosures but no Core assurance. ₹700 crore is 70% of AUM, so it passes the 65% bar (₹650 crore). If a couple of large holdings in the assured group were swapped for unassured mid-caps worth ₹60 crore, the assured slice would fall to ₹640 crore, or 64%, and the fund would be offside. That’s how quickly a portfolio tilt can bump into the line.
BRSR Core, in plain words
The BRSR is the sustainability report SEBI requires from large listed companies. BRSR Core is a smaller subset of it, chosen so it can be checked by an outside assurance provider. According to SEBI’s July 12, 2023 circular on BRSR Core, it is a set of key performance indicators under 9 ESG attributes. SEBI added a few India-specific indicators, such as job creation in small towns, openness of business and gross wages paid to women, and included intensity ratios based on revenue adjusted for purchasing power parity so the numbers are comparable globally.
That circular laid out who had to do what, and when:
- From FY 2023-24, the top 1,000 listed entities by market capitalisation had to make disclosures in the updated BRSR format in their annual reports.
- Reasonable assurance of BRSR Core was phased in: the top 150 listed entities for FY 2023-24, the top 250 for FY 2024-25, the top 500 for FY 2025-26 and the top 1,000 for FY 2026-27.
- Value-chain ESG disclosures, covering the top upstream and downstream partners that together make up 75% of a company’s purchases or sales by value, were to apply to the top 250 listed entities on a comply-or-explain basis from FY 2024-25, with limited assurance on a comply-or-explain basis from FY 2025-26.
One caution. The mutual fund master circular also refers to a later SEBI circular on BRSR Core dated December 20, 2024, so the original 2023 timetable shouldn’t be read as the final word. If you’re checking a specific company, its latest annual report will say what kind of assurance it actually obtained.
Why does this matter for a fund investor? Because the 65% rule leans on it. The wider the assurance net gets, the larger the pool of companies an ESG fund can count toward that 65%, and the more of the portfolio’s sustainability data rests on numbers that someone outside the company has checked.
What the scheme name has to tell you
This is the simplest check, and people skip it. SEBI requires the ESG strategy to appear in the scheme’s name. The master circular gives examples in the form “XYZ ESG Exclusionary Strategy Fund” and “ABC ESG Best-in-class Strategy Fund”. So before you look at returns, look at the name. If you want a fund that avoids certain businesses outright, an exclusion strategy is what you’re after. If you’re comfortable owning every sector as long as the fund picks the cleaner players in each, best-in-class is closer to that.
Worked example: two funds, one sector
Imagine two hypothetical funds looking at the same three cement companies, A, B and C. A has the lowest emissions intensity of the three, C the highest. These are made-up companies used only to show the logic.
- A fund running an exclusion strategy with a threshold on, say, emissions-heavy businesses might exclude all three if cement falls under its exclusion criteria, or keep all three if the threshold isn’t breached. It doesn’t rank them against each other.
- A fund running a best-in-class strategy would likely own A and skip C, because the strategy is about beating peers on disclosed metrics.
Neither is “more ESG” than the other. They answer different questions. The name tells you which question the fund is answering.
The monthly and annual disclosures worth reading
Here’s where an ESG fund has to show its homework. The master circular lists several disclosures beyond what a normal equity fund publishes.
Monthly portfolio statements must show security-wise BRSR Core scores, as and when SEBI-registered ESG Rating Providers (ERPs) make them available, along with BRSR scores. The fund must also name the ERPs providing its ESG scores, and if it switches rating provider, it has to give the reason in the next monthly statement.
Voting disclosures go a step further than usual. For each resolution, the AMC has to say plainly whether its vote for or against was driven by environmental, social or governance reasons. If the fund house votes differently for its ESG and non-ESG schemes, it has to disclose those votes and the reasoning separately.
The annual report must carry a fund manager commentary covering how the ESG strategy was applied, case studies of engagement with investee companies, the number of engagements in the year with the modes of communication and outcomes, annual tracking of ESG rating or score movements in the portfolio companies, the percentage of AUM in companies with no BRSR disclosures (investments made before October 1, 2022) and its impact on the fund score, and the reasons for any change of ERP.
If a fund house votes the same way on every resolution for its ESG and non-ESG schemes, ask yourself what the ESG label is adding.
Worked example: reading a voting record
Say a hypothetical AMC voted on 40 resolutions at portfolio companies in a quarter. Its ESG scheme’s voting rationale shows “against, governance reasons” on two related-party transactions and “for” on everything else, with no environmental or social reason cited anywhere. That’s not automatically a red flag, since many resolutions are routine. But if the fund calls itself an impact or transition strategy and its annual commentary lists zero engagements on emissions or labour issues, the paperwork and the label don’t match. We’d want to see at least some engagement tied to the stated objective, because the circular specifically asks schemes with a defined objective to report engagements and outcomes against it.
Who checks the fund?
Two layers of checking sit on top of the disclosures. First, the AMC must get an independent reasonable assurance every year on whether the ESG scheme’s portfolio complies with the strategy and objective stated in its Scheme Information Document (SID), and that assurance has to be disclosed in the scheme’s annual report. The assurance provider must have the expertise for the job and must not have a conflict of interest; the circular’s example is that the provider or its associates shouldn’t sell products or offer non-audit services, including consulting, to the AMC or its group.
Second, the AMC’s board has to certify, based on a comprehensive internal ESG audit, that the ESG schemes comply with the regulations, and disclose that in the annual reports. The internal audit is meant to verify the SIDs, stewardship reporting and the fund’s Responsible Investment Policy so that what those documents say is factual.
In practice, this means the annual report of an ESG scheme is a richer document than most investors assume. It’s where the assurance statement, the board certification and the fund manager commentary all live.
A quick checklist before you buy an ESG fund
- Read the strategy in the name. Exclusion, integration, best-in-class, impact, sustainable objectives or transition. Make sure it matches what you actually care about.
- Open the latest monthly portfolio. Check that BRSR scores and, where available, BRSR Core scores are shown, and note which rating provider is used.
- Look at the top ten holdings. If they look identical to a plain large-cap index fund, the strategy may be doing very little. That’s not illegal, but it changes what you’re paying for.
- Read the voting rationale. Look for resolutions where E, S or G reasons are actually cited.
- Find the annual assurance statement and board certification in the scheme’s annual report.
- Remember it’s equity. Size the position the way you would any thematic equity bet. Our guide to risk management in trading covers position sizing and drawdowns, and the same thinking applies to a concentrated fund.
The honest bottom line
SEBI’s framework doesn’t make any ESG fund a better investment. It doesn’t promise higher returns or lower risk, and nothing in the circular says it does. What it does is force each scheme to declare a strategy, invest most of its money in line with it, lean on companies whose sustainability data has been independently assured, and publish enough detail for you to check. That’s a real improvement over the days when “green” was whatever the brochure said it was. The work left for the investor is to actually read what gets published.
If you hold other specialised funds, our piece on the gold fund of funds walks through a similar exercise of reading the fine print before you invest.
Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks; read all scheme-related documents carefully. All portfolio figures and companies in the worked examples are hypothetical. Please consult a SEBI-registered investment adviser before making investment decisions.





Leave a Reply
Join the conversation
Commenting is open to registered readers. Sign up with just your email — no password needed, and it takes under a minute.
Sign up to comment Log in