Dalal Street Blogs provides information for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Please consult a SEBI-registered investment adviser before making any investment decisions.
CAUTION: Dalal Street Blogs publishes market news and educational content only. We do not promote, recommend or endorse any stock, and nothing here is a solicitation to buy or sell securities. Please consult a SEBI-registered adviser before investing.
Trading Strategy

Anchoring Bias in Trading: Why Your Buy Price Shouldn’t Decide Your Exit

3973
By Dalal Street Blogs EditorialUpdated 10 min read

You bought a stock at ₹500. It’s now at ₹410. The company has just cut its guidance, the sector is out of favour, and if someone handed you fresh cash today you wouldn’t touch it. Yet you hold, because “I’ll sell once it gets back to 500.” That number has nothing to do with what the business is worth. It’s simply where you happened to get in. This is anchoring bias in trading, and it’s one of the quieter ways traders lose money, because it rarely feels like a mistake while it’s happening.

Below we’ll look at what the research says about anchoring, how it shows up on an Indian trading screen, and a few practical checks that make it harder for one arbitrary number to run your exits. There are worked examples with made-up figures so the arithmetic is easy to follow.

In this article
  1. What is anchoring bias in trading?
  2. What the experiments actually found
  3. Where anchors show up on your trading screen
  4. How anchoring wrecks exits: two worked examples
  5. Anchoring bias vs other trading biases
  6. Practical ways to loosen the anchor
  7. When a reference price is legitimately useful
  8. A quick anchoring check before your next exit

What is anchoring bias in trading?

Psychologists describe the anchoring effect as the tendency for a judgement to be pulled towards a reference point, the “anchor”, even when that reference point is irrelevant. Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman formalised the idea in their 1974 paper in Science, “Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases”, where they described anchoring and adjustment as a shortcut people use to make estimates when they’re unsure.

The mechanism is simple. You start from a number you already have in your head, then adjust away from it. The trouble is that the adjustment tends to stop too early, so the final answer stays closer to the anchor than it should.

In markets, the anchor is almost always a price. Your buy price. Last year’s high. The level a stock traded at before a bad quarter. A target price from a report you read months ago. None of these is automatically wrong to look at. The problem starts when that number, rather than current information, decides what you do next.

What the experiments actually found

Two of the classic results are worth knowing because they show how little it takes to set an anchor.

In one study, Tversky and Kahneman gave people five seconds to estimate the product of the numbers one to eight. One group saw it written as 1 × 2 × 3 × … × 8, the other as 8 × 7 × 6 × … × 1. Nobody had time to finish, so everyone guessed from the first few steps. The ascending group’s median estimate was 512. The descending group’s was 2,250. The correct answer is 40,320. Both groups were way off, and the order in which the numbers appeared was enough to pull their guesses apart.

In another, participants watched a wheel that was rigged to stop on either 10 or 65, then estimated the percentage of African countries in the United Nations. Those who saw 10 guessed about 25% on average. Those who saw 65 guessed about 45%. A number everyone knew was random still moved the answer by around 20 percentage points.

If a number from a spinning wheel can move people’s estimates, the price you paid for a stock can certainly move your decision to sell it.

Two further findings matter for traders. First, anchoring is hard to switch off. In experiments summarised in the same research overview, participants who were told outright that the anchor would “contaminate” their answers still gave estimates skewed towards it. Second, of the debiasing methods tested, the most reliable has been the “consider-the-opposite” approach, where you deliberately argue the case against your current view. We’ll use that idea later.

There’s finance-specific evidence too. One study of an app-based brokerage found that an investor’s first purchase price became an anchor for later purchases, and that people who started with a small purchase ended up with less invested over the long run. Separately, research on house prices found that the two-year and nine-year highs of the Case-Shiller index worked as anchors in predicting current prices. Past highs stick in people’s heads.

Where anchors show up on your trading screen

Once you start looking, you’ll see anchors all over a typical trader’s day.

  • Your average buy price. Most broker apps print it right next to the live price, along with a red or green P&L. It’s the most visible number on the screen, and it’s the one the market cares about least.
  • The 52-week high. “It was at 1,200 last year, so 800 is cheap” sounds like analysis. It isn’t, unless something about the business says 1,200 was justified and still is.
  • The IPO price. It’s tempting to treat the issue price as a fair-value floor, and to talk about a stock “trading below its IPO price” as if that alone made it a bargain.
  • Round numbers and old targets. A target you set three months ago, or a round figure like 1,000, can quietly become the exit even after the reasons behind it have changed.
  • The pre-fall price. After a sharp drop, the level just before the fall becomes the reference point. Everything below it looks like a discount.

Each of these is a fact about the past. None of them, on its own, tells you where the stock should trade next.

How anchoring wrecks exits: two worked examples

The figures below are hypothetical and don’t refer to any real stock.

Example 1: waiting to “get back to breakeven”

Ravi buys 200 shares at ₹500, so he has ₹1,00,000 in the trade. His plan said he’d exit below ₹460. The stock drifts to ₹455, then ₹430. He moves the mental stop to “I’ll exit at cost”. It slides to ₹400.

At ₹400 the position is worth ₹80,000, a loss of ₹20,000, or 20% of what he put in. Here’s the uncomfortable arithmetic: to get back to ₹500 from ₹400, the stock now has to rise 25% (₹100 on a base of ₹400). Had he exited at ₹460 as planned, his loss would have been ₹8,000, or 8%.

What went wrong wasn’t the original trade. It was letting ₹500, a number the market doesn’t know or care about, replace the exit rule he set before the emotions kicked in.

Example 2: selling the winner too early

Anchoring cuts the other way too. Meera buys 100 shares at ₹200. It runs to ₹240 within two weeks, a 20% gain. Results are strong, volumes are rising and her setup is still intact. But 20% “feels like enough” compared with her buy price, so she sells and books ₹4,000.

If the stock goes on to ₹280, she’s left another ₹4,000 on the table. Maybe it doesn’t, and selling turns out fine. The point is that her decision was based on distance from ₹200, not on whether the reasons for owning the stock still held.

Put the two examples together and you get a familiar pattern: cutting winners quickly and riding losers for too long. That’s the disposition effect. When Hersh Shefrin and Meir Statman coined the term in 1985, one of the four psychological elements they named was mental accounting that tracks each holding relative to its original purchase price. In other words, an anchor sits at the centre of it.

Anchoring bias vs other trading biases

Anchoring rarely shows up alone, and it helps to know the neighbours.

Loss aversion is about how much a loss hurts compared with a gain of the same size. Anchoring decides what counts as a loss in the first place: below your buy price is “red”, above it is “green”. The two together make it feel unbearable to sell under cost.

Recency bias gives too much weight to the last few sessions. It can actually create new anchors. A stock that hit ₹900 last week makes ₹850 look cheap today, simply because ₹900 is fresh in your memory.

Confirmation bias keeps the anchor in place. Once you’ve decided the stock is “worth” ₹500, you notice the bullish headlines and skim past the bearish ones.

Practical ways to loosen the anchor

The research suggests you can’t just decide not to be anchored. Being aware of it didn’t save the participants who were warned. So the fixes that work tend to be structural: rules and routines that take the anchor out of the moment of decision.

1. Write the exit before you enter

Decide your stop-loss and your conditions for taking profit when you place the trade, and base them on the chart or the business, not on round percentages from cost. A stop under a recent swing low, or a level where the trade idea is clearly wrong, is defensible. “I’ll sell if I’m down 10%” is still anchored to your entry, though it’s better than having no exit at all. If you use percentage stops, at least size the position so that the rupee loss at the stop is a fixed small part of your capital. Our risk management guide covers position sizing in detail.

2. Ask the fresh-money question

For every holding, ask: “If I had this amount in cash today, would I buy this stock at this price?” If the honest answer is no, your buy price is the only thing keeping you in. This is a practical version of the consider-the-opposite approach that researchers found most reliable for reducing anchoring.

3. Hide the buy price for a day

If your broker app lets you switch the portfolio view away from P&L, or view a chart without your average cost marked on it, try it for a day. Reviewing positions without the entry price staring back at you is a small change, but it shifts attention to where the stock is now and what it’s doing.

4. Argue the other side in writing

Before adding to a loser or exiting a winner, write two or three lines making the strongest case for the opposite action. If you’re about to average down, write out why you’d sell instead. If you’re about to book profit, write out why you’d hold. Most of the time you’ll still do what you planned. Occasionally the exercise shows that the only argument on your side is a number from the past.

5. Use trailing stops on winners

A trailing stop follows the price up and exits only when the stock falls back by a set amount or breaks a defined level. It moves the decision away from “how much am I up from my buy price” towards “is the trend still intact”. Meera, in the example above, could have trailed a stop under each new higher low instead of selling at a round 20%.

The market has no idea what you paid. Your exit plan shouldn’t depend on it either.

6. Review closed trades by decision, not by outcome

Once a month, go through your exits and tag any where the stated reason was “back to cost”, “round number” or “felt like enough”. Count them. If those trades consistently gave up more than your rule-based exits, you have hard evidence of what anchoring is costing you, which is far more persuasive than a general warning.

When a reference price is legitimately useful

None of this means past prices are useless. Support and resistance levels are, in a sense, collective anchors. Lots of traders remember the same level, so the price often reacts there. Reading those levels on a chart is a valid part of technical analysis.

The difference is whose anchor it is. A level where many buyers and sellers have traded before is market information. Your personal entry price is not. One reflects what the crowd did. The other only reflects when you clicked buy.

Similarly, comparing a valuation multiple to its own history is fine when you also ask why it has changed. “It traded at 40 times earnings before, so 25 is cheap” only holds if growth, margins and risk look the same as they did then.

A quick anchoring check before your next exit

  • Is my reason to sell (or hold) based on current price action or business information, or on my buy price?
  • Would I buy this stock today, at this price, with fresh money?
  • Did I set this exit before the trade, and if I’m changing it now, what new information justifies the change?
  • Am I treating a 52-week high, IPO price or old target as the stock’s “real” value?
  • Have I written down the case for doing the opposite?

Anchoring won’t disappear because you know about it. The experiments are clear on that. But a written plan, a fresh-money test and a habit of arguing the other side make it much harder for one old number to decide your next trade.

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. The worked examples use hypothetical figures and do not refer to any real company or stock. Trading involves risk of loss. Please consult a SEBI-registered investment adviser before making investment decisions.

Leave a Reply

Join the conversation

Commenting is open to registered readers. Sign up with just your email — no password needed, and it takes under a minute.

Sign up to comment Log in